Today’s topic is data, specifically what the numbers can tell you about the state of Christian publishing. Understanding the market matters for your success as an author. You don’t want to be blind to what’s happening around you, and one way to see it clearly is to look at the data. You need to know what’s popular, what the trends are, what’s not popular, and what’s growing, is key to writing books people actually want to read.

To dig into what the data shows, Alex Newton joins the show. He’s the founder of K-lytics.com (Affiliate Link), a leading market research resource that helps authors and publishers understand the market. Based in Germany, he spent 20 years as a market consultant for large corporations before shifting his focus to working with authors, a change worth being grateful for. K-lytics specializes in the Amazon market, and specifically the Amazon ebook market, one of the richest sources of publishing data available.

What is K-lytics?

Alex: K stands for Kindle, and lytics is for analytics. It was originally going to be called Kindle-lytics, but we wanted to avoid a trademark dispute on day one, so four years ago, when we started, we landed on K-lytics instead.

What does K-lytics do for authors?

Alex: In essence, we help publishers and authors make better, faster publishing decisions, including decisions about which book projects to pursue and how to position them.

If you already have a project, we help you tailor it toward what the market is receptive to. If you don’t have one yet, we can point you to the specific market segments, within Christian fiction, which is a vast market, where demand is highest and competition, meaning the number of titles and competing authors, is lowest.

We bring an economic and business point of view to the arts. I was at a conference recently where the theme was “where science meets the arts.” That’s essentially what we do.

Why does category selection matters?

Alex: Choosing the right category doesn’t require rewriting your book, but it can completely change how easily readers find it.

Thomas: This is key, and it doesn’t have to change your book much.

In a real bookstore your book would be placed on one of a few shelves. It might be on Christian romance, current issues, or maybe women’s fiction. Knowing which shelf gets more foot traffic matters, but so does knowing which shelf is more crowded. One shelf might hold 10,000 books, another only 1,000.

It’s much easier to make a name for yourself on the less crowded shelf, especially on Amazon, where the number one book in any category gets a bestseller badge that adds real credibility. Some Amazon categories only have 100 or 200 books in them, which means becoming a number one bestseller only requires outselling 100 or 200 other books, a huge difference from categories with tens of thousands of competing titles.

A lot of authors say, “I’m just going to write the book that’s on my heart, the story God gave me, and I’m not going to worry about the market.” The problem is that publishers do care about the market. They want to publish books people want to read, and hopefully you want to write a book people want to read too. This data gives you a real idea of what that is.

Alex: Exactly. Publishers look at the data, and so do hybrid and indie authors, and those pursuing a traditional publisher. The data can help you build your own business case. If you’re pitching a publisher or an agent, you can point out that you’re writing in the highest-growing segment, that it isn’t overly crowded, that it’s a big new trend. Books are being sold, so the laws of supply and demand apply, even in the arts. Mozart faced this. So did Leonardo da Vinci. If people don’t pay for the work, you have a problem.

What do authors need to know about Amazon’s data?

Thomas: I get many proposals every day, and it’s clear that very few authors have access to this kind of data or any real awareness of how popular various categories or books actually are. They might vaguely know a book is a bestseller, but not how well it’s actually selling.

What should authors know about Amazon specifically? What makes this platform different from other places people buy books?

Alex: We treat Amazon data as a representative snapshot of the overall book market, for two reasons. First, Amazon claims about 85% of the ebook market, and some estimates put it even higher. Second, the big-selling genres, romance, mystery, suspense, sci-fi and fantasy, and literature and fiction generally, have very high ebook penetration.

Audio is growing too, and print is getting squeezed in between. So the ebook market gives you the best data available. Within Christian books specifically, most people don’t realize that Amazon alone has 295 book categories, or subgenres, in the Christian book market.

About 100 of those are Christian fiction. The rest is Christian nonfiction, which gets very granular. In fiction, we counted 102 submarkets as of October this year, and they vary widely in performance, competition, and even pricing. On the demand side, religion and spirituality is roughly the 6th or 7th highest-selling category in the Kindle store, in the same range as teen and young adult, and biographies and memoirs, behind the big categories like romance, mystery, thriller, suspense, and sci-fi.

We’ve tracked the religion and spirituality bestseller list for four years now, and over that time it’s shown a steady upward trend. Christian books are clearly being read on Kindle, and that in turn feeds the print market too.

They’re mutually beneficial. Within religion, the Christian books and Bibles category sells very well overall, and the biggest market within religion and spirituality is clearly Christian fiction.

Thomas: When you say print is getting squeezed between ebooks and audiobooks, that’s specific to fiction. Print is alive and well in nonfiction, and it’s still popular in fiction too, just less so than 20 years ago. Lots of people, especially younger readers, still prefer paper.

What Trends Emerged in Christian Fiction in 2018?

Thomas: So, what trends have you seen in Christian fiction over 2018? What’s gained popularity, and what’s lost it?

Alex: If you track bestseller lists over time, a few of these 102 subcategories always stand out. One interesting phenomenon on Amazon is the “classics” category, which exists across genres like romance, sci-fi, and mystery, not just religion and spirituality. You’d assume you couldn’t compete there, but you can, because nobody actually defines what qualifies as a classic. We’ve found that classics has been on the rise, and inside it are plenty of new, contemporary Christian fiction titles.

Thomas: Are these indie books hacking Amazon’s category system, since you can put almost any category on a book, or are they traditionally published titles the publisher considers classics because they’ve been out a few years?

Alex: It’s certainly a mix. Some indie authors have known about this hack for a while, but there are also legitimate classics in there. I doubt traditional publishers are consciously deciding this, though. They’re not playing the category game on Kindle yet.

This kind of category strategy has a name, and it’s currently one of indie publishing’s quieter advantages.

Thomas: Picking competitive categories that are popular but not crowded can give a book a huge advantage over comparable titles, and it’s one of the reasons indie books have been gaining market share on Amazon.

Over the past year, traditional publishing has dropped in fiction while indie publishing has gained significantly, enough that publishers are actually starting to see it hit their bottom line. I’d give indies maybe six more months of winning at this before traditional publishers get access to data like K-lytics, start using it effectively, and the market rebalances. That advantage will go away eventually, but right now it’s one of those quiet hacks that still works if you’re willing to be thoughtful about it, and I wanted listeners to know about it while it does.

It’s not a hack in the sense that it breaks the rules, though putting your book in “classics” is a bit of an edge case. In general, there are usually five or six categories that could reasonably describe your book, and knowing which one is the best fit can give it a real advantage.

Which Christian fiction categories rose and fell in 2018?

Alex: Zooming out from classics to the broader category list, the last 12 to 18 months show some clear winners and losers.

Beyond classics, religious and biblical fiction saw a sales rank improvement of about 50-60% over the past 12 months. It’s still one of the smaller segments in absolute terms, but the 18-month trend is clear. Spirituality and inspirational fiction rose a similar 50%. On the other end, historical religious fiction trended down through 2018, and religious science fiction and fantasy lost about 50% of its sales rank over the same period.

Thomas: You break my heart, Alex, that’s my category. Just to be clear, that’s a 50% drop over the last year in religious science fiction and fantasy specifically.

Alex: Right. To be clear, we’re tracking the average rank of these bestseller positions over time, not individual books. In absolute terms, the average sales rank across the top 20 titles we track was around 6,000, out of 4.5 million books, back in April 2017. By October 2018, that had dropped to somewhere around 14,000 to 16,000. It’s been a steady, continuous decline, not an outlier blip, and that’s exactly the kind of trend worth watching over time.

Does a falling sales rank mean less competition?

Thomas: A falling sales rank sounds like an opening for new authors, but it isn’t quite that simple.

Looking at the graph now, most of the data points are trending down. Does that mean it’s actually easier to write a bestselling Christian fantasy or sci-fi book right now, because the competition is lower?

Alex: Unfortunately, not necessarily. What I just described is a measure of demand, the sales rank of books in a category. Supply is a completely different picture. Overall, there are about 450,000 Christian titles across religion and spirituality, and the bulk of that is Christian literature. It’s a very competitive, big market with many opportunities and niches, but the largest categories still carry a lot of competition. Let me actually pull up my database and check the current competition level for religious science fiction specifically, as we’re talking.

Thomas: There are really two kinds of competition: how many books you’re up against, and how strong the best-performing books in that category actually are. If the top books are underperforming compared to before, it might be easier to write something good enough to break into that top tier. But how many people you’re racing against still matters. You need to run a lot faster to win a marathon with 100,000 people in it than one with five people from your gym class.

Alex: Exactly right. For religious science fiction and fantasy, we’re talking about roughly 6,500 competing titles, a genuine niche market, not especially competitive. Right now, the number one bestseller in that category is selling around 200 copies a day.

How is Christian romance performing?

Thomas: Christian fiction leans heavily on romance, so it’s worth a closer look at how that category is doing on its own.

That 200 copies a day is nothing to sneeze at. How has Christian romance done over the past year?

Alex: Overall, it’s doing well. Over the last 12 months, sales have been fairly static, but the 18-month trend is up, and when you weigh demand against the level of competition, religious, inspirational, and Christian romance categories are all performing very well. Part of that comes down to Kindle’s demographics: women 55 and older are a large share of Kindle device owners, and probably 70-75% of device owners overall are female, even though more and more people now read the Kindle app on other devices entirely. Since the Christian and religious fiction market is itself huge, you get this natural overlap between romance and Christian or inspirational themes, which is why subcategories like biblical fiction, Amish romance, and Western or Christian frontier romance sell so well relative to how competitive they actually are.

There are traditionally published, hybrid, and self-published authors making a genuinely good income across all of these categories right now.

What are some uncrowded categories in Christian fiction?

Alex: We segment the market into three broad groups. First are “hot sells,” categories with under 2,000 titles that can still grow into something bigger. A few really stand out for demand relative to their size: religious mystery is a big one, and so is inspirational fiction and spirituality, which sounds like a huge market but is actually quite a small category.

Biblical fiction is a very small market, but with surprisingly good demand. Religious women’s fiction fits here too.

Next are “hot niches,” book markets with anything from 2,000 to 10,000 titles, not too small and not too big. Christian fiction westerns are doing extremely well in this range, and so are collections and anthologies, an umbrella category that covers a lot of shorter, series-style books.

Historical romance, as we mentioned earlier, is trending slightly down, but it’s still a very attractive market from an absolute standpoint.

Thomas: And it’s only a slight decline, closer to 4% than the 50% drop we saw in science fiction. On a graph, it barely dips. It could easily pick back up next month. I’m hoping fantasy and science fiction bounce back next year too. Someone please write some good Christian fantasy with dragons, monsters, spaceships, and all of it.

Alex: Absolutely. Contemporary romance within Christian fiction is another category that sounds bigger than it is from a supply standpoint.

What we tend to see is mainstream trends getting adapted into Christian fiction. Take the billionaire romance wave that followed Fifty Shades of Grey, built on the classic Cinderella trope of a girl swept up by a billionaire. Authors have reworked it into cleaner, wholesome, or explicitly Christian versions, sometimes with those exact words, “clean Christian billionaire romance,” right in the title. Mainstream developments get adapted for the Christian fiction audience again and again, and some of these adaptations do incredibly well.

Thomas: There’s nothing new under the sun. Finding Nemo is really The Odyssey, with Marlin as Odysseus fighting his way back to his family. Or The Lion King, which is just Hamlet with animals in the jungle. Old stories get retold in every generation, and there’s nothing wrong with borrowing the bones of a proven story and making it feel new.

Where Can Readers Get the Full K-lytics Christian Fiction Report?

Thomas: We’ve only scratched the surface of your report, which runs over 60 pages. If people want the full picture, maybe on a category we didn’t cover, where can they find it?

Alex: Go to k-lytics.com and then to the Christian fiction section, and you’ll find the report there.

Thomas: My favorite page in these reports is always the covers. You’ll see a page of the most popular covers over the last year, and it’s a great way to spot cover trends, something that’s genuinely hard to describe in words but obvious once you see it laid out.

Connect with Alex Newton